Best Luxury Boutique Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

In the heart of Greenport, where the charm of coastal New York intertwines with modern luxury, The Menhaden Hotel stands as a serene retreat. This boutique haven invites couples and adventurers alike to indulge in its intimate atmosphere, where every detail has been crafted for an unforgettable escape.

Romantic Hideaway - With inviting decor and thoughtfully curated amenities, The Menhaden Hotel provides a sanctuary for romance. Guests revel in the cozy ambiance of their air-conditioned rooms, each adorned with unique touches that whisper comfort and warmth.

Outstanding Location - Located just steps from the ferry terminal, the hotel offers seamless access to nearby Shelter Island, encouraging spontaneous explorations fueled by the sea breeze. The vibrant local markets and historic sights beckon cultural explorers seeking the essence of Long Island.

Wellbeing Retreat - Experience tranquility at The Menhaden Hotel, where wellness is woven into every moment. Revel in the rooftop lounge with breathtaking views, or enjoy self-serve breakfast accompanied by the aroma of fresh croissants and artisanal teas during cherished afternoon gatherings.

Guest Experiences - Guests are greeted by friendly staff who not only serve but also share delightful recommendations, such as hidden gems nearby. The attention to detail shines through small gestures, like an evening tea time filled with warm cookies and intriguing snacks that make every stay feel uniquely personalized.

Perched elegantly on the fringes of Greenport’s vibrant waterfront, The Harbor Front Inn invites guests into a realm where modern luxury intertwines with the intimate charm of a seaside retreat. Each sunrise casts a golden hue over the shimmering waters, creating an inviting backdrop for couples and travelers seeking a romantic escape or a rejuvenating getaway.

Outstanding Location - Just moments away from quaint boutiques and artisanal eateries, The Harbor Front Inn places you at the heart of Greenport's lively charm, making it easy to stroll through the picturesque streets or relish a sunset by the harbor.

Romantic Retreat - With select rooms boasting private balconies that frame stunning views, this boutique hotel offers an idyllic setting for lovebirds; imagine sipping wine as the sun sinks below the horizon, painting the sky in hues of orange and pink.

Wellness Experiences - Beyond its chic accommodations, The Harbor Front Inn features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, perfect for a refreshing dip after a day of exploration, while wellness enthusiasts can indulge in yoga sessions for total relaxation amidst serene surroundings.

Guest Experiences - Guests fondly recall the warm hospitality of the staff, who seamlessly blend professionalism with genuine friendliness, ensuring every need is met — from sharing local dining recommendations to serving up a fresh cup of coffee on a leisurely morning.

In the heart of Greenport, NY, where charming streets meet the tranquil waters of Long Island, American Beech Hotel beckons with its chic design and intimate ambiance. This luxury boutique hotel offers a sanctuary for couples, adventure seekers, and cultural explorers alike, inviting every guest to bask in the seamless blend of modern comfort and captivating local charm.

Chic Boutique Experience - Every corner of American Beech Hotel exudes sophistication, from the meticulously designed rooms that combine contemporary elements with warm, inviting touches, to the vibrant garden where guests can unwind amidst the lush greenery.

Outstanding Location - Perfectly positioned at the crossroads of Greenport’s lively district, guests can easily wander to nearby boutiques, artisanal markets, and exquisite dining, ensuring an enriching experience right at their doorstep.

Culinary Delights - The on-site restaurant and bar serve as a culinary haven, where guests are treated to expertly crafted cocktails and locally sourced dishes, creating a delightful backdrop for leisurely evenings spent savoring the moment.

Guest Experiences - Recent visitors have relished the tranquility of the garden while enjoying expertly made drinks at the bar, sharing anecdotes of friendly staff who made them feel instantly at home — even describing the continental breakfast as 'delicious' and a perfect start to their day.

In the charming coastal village of Greenport, where the gentle whispers of the Long Island Sound meet the vibrant colors of the North Fork’s landscapes, Sound View Greenport invites discerning travelers to unwind in an intimate haven of luxury. Here, every detail is thoughtfully curated, offering a serene retreat that envelops guests in tranquility and elegance.

Outstanding Location - Perched alongside the shimmering shores, this boutique hotel boasts panoramic views that captivate the senses; countless guests have marveled at the way they can 'sit in bed and stare at the sound,' as the soothing rhythm of the waves becomes a cherished backdrop to their stay.

Romantic Escape - Perfect for couples seeking an idyllic getaway, Sound View provides secluded accommodations brimming with character. The spacious suites, adorned with chic design elements, allow guests to indulge in moments of intimacy while basking in the glow of sunset hues reflecting off the water.

Wellbeing Experiences - Elevate your experience with rejuvenating wellness offerings designed to inspire relaxation and self-care. Guests have described mornings spent practicing yoga by the beach before enjoying a dip in the seasonal outdoor pool, creating an atmosphere of total tranquility.

Guest Experiences - 'The cleanliness and view were spectacular,' one guest remarked, while another was enchanted by witnessing a solar eclipse from their suite, underscoring the unique moments that transform a stay into an unforgettable memory.