Best Luxury Boutique Hotels in Amagansett

Nestled between the shimmering Atlantic Ocean and serene coastal landscapes, Amagansett embodies the quintessential charm of the Hamptons with its rustic elegance and artistic spirit. Known for its striking beaches, vibrant local art scene, and farm-to-table dining options, this enchanting village offers a refreshing escape from the ordinary. Among its myriad offerings, the boutique hotel scene in Amagansett stands out, providing travelers with a unique blend of personalized service and distinct character. The Roundtree, Amagansett, captures the essence of laid-back luxury with its beautifully designed spaces that evoke a sense of tranquility and connection to nature. Just a short drive away, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa entices guests with its breathtaking oceanfront views and rejuvenating wellness experiences. Meanwhile, Journey East Hampton invites visitors to indulge in an inviting atmosphere that reflects the local culture and artistry. For those seeking the Best Luxury Boutique Hotels in Amagansett, these gems promise unforgettable stays. Embark on your journey today by exploring our curated collection and let Amagansett enchant you.

List Of Best Boutique Hotels Amagansett

The Roundtree, Amagansett
Hotels
273 Main Street, PO box 799, Amagansett, NY 11930, USA

In the heart of Amagansett, where sandy shores meet serene landscapes, The Roundtree beckons with its enchanting allure. This luxury boutique hotel offers a haven for discerning travelers seeking both tranquility and sophistication, featuring intimate accommodations that whisper elegance and warmth.

Chic Boutique Retreat - Every corner of The Roundtree exudes character, from its thoughtfully curated cabins to the lush, inviting gardens. Here, guests can unwind in their private sanctuaries, surrounded by rustic charm and modern comforts.

Culinary Delights - Start your day with a delightful breakfast that tantalizes the senses; fresh ingredients and local flavors are at the forefront, ensuring each meal is a celebration of the region's bounty, perfectly complemented by warm, attentive service.

Secluded Setting - Ideal for romance or reflection, the hotel’s tranquil environment invites leisurely strolls through its manicured grounds. Guests often find themselves gathered around cozy bonfires under the stars, sharing stories and laughter in this idyllic setting.

Guest Experiences - From the moment you step into your cabin, you’ll find an array of complimentary snacks and Nespresso coffee waiting, making every morning feel like a luxurious treat. The friendliness of the staff adds a personal touch that guests cherish, creating memories of cherished moments spent in this hidden gem.

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Hotels
290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954, USA

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a sanctuary where the rhythmic lull of ocean waves harmonizes with luxurious comfort, offering an intimate retreat along the breathtaking shores of Montauk. With its chic design complementing the natural beauty of the coastline, this resort captures the essence of upscale relaxation and invites guests to indulge in a world of serenity.

Spa & Wellness Experiences - Immerse yourself in rejuvenation at the full-service spa, featuring healing treatments that incorporate the restorative properties of ocean-fed seawater. Guests have marveled at the tranquil ambiance, where the aroma of sea salt and essential oils wafts through the air, allowing for a truly transformative escape.

Outstanding Location - Just steps from the beach, Gurney's offers unparalleled views of the Atlantic, where sunrise casts a golden glow over tranquil waters. Guests have shared moments of pure bliss, sipping cocktails on private balconies while soaking in the sun-drenched vistas, creating memories framed by nature's artistry.

Culinary Delights - With five distinct dining venues, culinary exploration becomes a delightful adventure. Reviewers rave about the delectable offerings, from fresh seafood that transports your taste buds to the coast to artisanal dishes crafted from local ingredients, all enjoyed amidst an elegant setting that feels both sophisticated and inviting.

Guest Experiences - One guest recalled the joy of their children splashing in the indoor pool, while they unwound in the serene bathhouse, marveling at the stunning decor that whispers luxury. Another couple reminisced about cozy evenings spent by the fire pit, wrapped in plush blankets, as the scent of the sea mingled with the fragrance of gourmet food wafting from the nearby restaurant.

Journey East Hampton
Hotels
490 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA

Journey East Hampton invites you to step into a serene oasis where modern elegance intertwines with the enchanting charm of East Hampton. As the gentle sea breeze whispers through the lush gardens, guests find themselves enveloped in an atmosphere of luxury and intimacy, perfect for romantic getaways or tranquil retreats from everyday life.

Intimate Retreat - With rooms that blend chic design and comfort, each space offers a private sanctuary adorned with plush bedding and stylish furnishings, ensuring restful nights after days filled with exploration.

Wellness Experiences - Guests are encouraged to unwind and rejuvenate by the lovely seasonal outdoor swimming pool, framed by verdant landscapes, or indulge in soothing moments at the firepit, where evenings transform into cozy gatherings.

Outstanding Location - Just a short bike ride from pristine beaches, Journey East Hampton places you within easy reach of the area's natural beauty, making it an ideal base for adventures in the Hamptons' captivating surroundings.

Guest Experiences - Visitors have remarked on the delightful ambiance, with one guest sharing how the lobby felt like home, perfectly designed for relaxing conversations. Others have cherished the evening ritual of roasting s'mores by the firepit, creating sweet memories against a backdrop of laughter and camaraderie.

Topping Rose House
Hotels
1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932, USA

In the heart of Bridgehampton, Topping Rose House invites discerning travelers to indulge in an ambiance where luxury seamlessly intertwines with rustic charm. With its immaculate blend of modern design and intimate character, this boutique hotel serves as a serene retreat for couples and solo adventurers alike, promising tranquility just moments away from the vibrant East End of Long Island.

Spa & Wellness - Unwind in a sanctuary of relaxation with a full-service spa offering rejuvenating treatments that harness the essence of nature, complemented by daily yoga sessions aimed at achieving total wellbeing.

Culinary Excellence - Savor each bite at the on-site farm-to-table restaurant, where every dish reflects a commitment to seasonal ingredients, many harvested from the hotel's own acre of fertile land, enticing foodies to explore the rich tapestry of local flavors.

Artful Ambiance - Immerse yourself in a curated collection of art peppered throughout the property, with stunning pieces that provide a visual feast and inspire appreciation for local culture amidst the hotel's chic, minimalistic design.

Guest Experiences - One guest remarked on the 'lovely beds' that cradled them into blissful slumber after evenings spent relishing exquisite meals, while another cherished the expansive spaces that invite effortless gatherings among friends.

Compare the Best Luxury Boutique Hotels in Amagansett – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Hotel Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
The Roundtree, Amagansett 273 Main Street, PO box 799, Amagansett, NY 11930, USA 1462 5 9.5 30 Click here
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 290 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954, USA 525 5 8 198 Click here
Journey East Hampton 490 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA 800 4 8 125 Click here
Topping Rose House 1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932, USA 2095 5 7.2 12 Click here

Note: The prices for each boutique hotels in Amagansett do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Amagansett Luxury Boutique Hotels on the Map View

Frequently Asked Questions

Popular luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett that have a pool include:

Transportation/Shuttle service is available at the following luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett:

A spa is available to guests at the following luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett:

Some of the best luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett include The Fisherman's Cottage and The Amagansett Beach House. Each offers unique amenities and a charming atmosphere, perfect for travelers looking to indulge.

Luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett typically offer high-end amenities such as private beach access, gourmet dining options, and personalized concierge services. Guests can also enjoy spa treatments and beautifully designed rooms.

Yes, some luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett are pet-friendly. It's advisable to check with individual hotels regarding their pet policies and any associated fees to ensure a comfortable stay for you and your furry friend.

The best time to visit Amagansett for a luxury getaway is during the summer months, from June to August, when the weather is warm and ideal for beach activities. However, spring and fall also offer a quieter, more relaxed experience.

You can easily book a stay at a luxury boutique hotel in Amagansett through their official websites or by using popular travel booking platforms. It's a good idea to compare rates and check for special packages that may enhance your stay.

Absolutely! Many luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett feature on-site restaurants that serve gourmet cuisine, showcasing local flavors and seasonal ingredients. Some hotels even offer room service for a more private dining experience.

When choosing a luxury boutique hotel in Amagansett, consider factors such as location, amenities, guest reviews, and the overall ambiance. Look for hotels that align with your personal style and offer services that cater to your needs.

While most luxury boutique hotels in Amagansett are not strictly all-inclusive, some do offer package deals that include meals, spa treatments, and other services. Be sure to inquire about these options when booking your stay.

3-Day Amagansett Itinerary If You're Staying at a Luxury Hotel

Day 1:

  • Morning: Start your day with a delicious breakfast at the Amagansett Sweet Shop, known for its fresh pastries and coffee.
  • Afternoon: Stroll through the charming streets of Amagansett and explore the local boutiques, then visit the Amagansett Museum to learn about the rich history of the area.
  • Evening: Enjoy a fine dining experience at The Lobster Roll, where you can indulge in fresh seafood while soaking in the coastal ambiance.

Day 2:

  • Morning: Have breakfast at The Cafe at Water Mill, which offers farm-to-table options in a cozy setting.
  • Afternoon: Head to Amagansett Beach for some sun and surf; it’s a perfect spot for relaxation and enjoying the stunning ocean views.
  • Evening: Unwind with a glass of wine at Water Mill Vineyards, where you can savor local wines in a beautiful vineyard setting.

Day 3:

  • Morning: Savor a leisurely brunch at Breakers American Grill, renowned for its hearty breakfast offerings.
  • Afternoon: Visit the Montauk Point State Park for breathtaking cliffs and iconic lighthouse views; it's a great place for photo opportunities.
  • Evening: Indulge in an exquisite dinner at Stone Creek Inn, where you can savor chef-inspired dishes in a refined atmosphere.

🛏️ Hotels perfect for this itinerary: The Roundtree, Amagansett Beach House, The Hermitage

Where to Stay in Amagansett: Best Areas by Traveler Type

Choosing the right area to stay in Amagansett is crucial for enhancing your travel experience, as it greatly depends on your specific needs and preferences. This charming coastal town features diverse neighborhoods that cater to various types of travelers. Whether you're seeking romance, family-friendly activities, or serene solitude, our guide will help you pinpoint the best fit for your stay in Amagansett.

👫 Where to Stay in Amagansett for Couples

Best Areas: Amagansett Village, Beachfront Area

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Village offers quaint charm and intimate dining options for romantic evenings. The Beachfront Area provides stunning sunsets and beach walks that are perfect for couples.

Top Hotels: The Atlantic Hotel, The Amagansett Beach & Bicycle Club

Top Features: Romantic views, Charming restaurants, Private beach access


👨‍👩‍👧 Where to Stay in Amagansett with Family

Best Areas: Amagansett Village, Napeague

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Village has parks and community activities that are engaging for kids. Napeague offers larger accommodations with family suites, plus access to kid-friendly beaches.

Top Hotels: Haven's Beach House, Napeague Oceanfront Inn

Top Features: Family-friendly beaches, Spacious common areas, Kids’ activity programs


🧳 Where to Stay in Amagansett for Solo Travelers

Best Areas: Amagansett Village, Near the Train Station

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Village is vibrant and walkable, allowing solo travelers to explore shops and cafes easily. Staying near the Train Station offers easy access to other parts of the Hamptons.

Top Hotels: The Roundtree, Amagansett Sea Change

Top Features: Cafes within walking distance, Social atmosphere, Easy transportation access


👵👴 Where to Stay in Amagansett for Seniors

Best Areas: Amagansett Village, Beachfront Area

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Village has a relaxed pace and plenty of accessible amenities. The Beachfront Area allows for leisurely strolls along the shore, ideal for enjoying nature.

Top Hotels: The Surf Lodge, Cliffside Resort

Top Features: Accessibility, Scenic views, Quiet surroundings


💸 Where to Stay in Amagansett on a Budget

Best Areas: Amagansett Village, Napeague

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Village offers affordable dining and activities, making it budget-friendly. Napeague provides cost-effective lodging options with access to beautiful beaches.

Top Hotels: Amagansett Motel, Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club

Top Features: Affordable dining options, Access to public transit, Community events


💎 Where to Stay in Amagansett for Luxury

Best Areas: Amagansett Beachfront, Private Estates

Why it’s perfect: Amagansett Beachfront features upscale resorts with stunning ocean views and top-tier amenities. Private Estates offer exclusivity and personalized services for discerning travelers.

Top Hotels: The White Fences Inn, The Surf Lodge (Luxury Suites)

Top Features: Gourmet dining experiences, Spa facilities, Private beach access


Where to Stay in Amagansett - Quick Guide

Traveler Type Best Areas Top Features
Couples Amagansett Village, Beachfront Area Romantic views, Charming restaurants, Private beach access
Family Amagansett Village, Napeague Family-friendly beaches, Spacious common areas, Kids’ activity programs
Solo Amagansett Village, Near the Train Station Cafes within walking distance, Social atmosphere, Easy transportation access
Seniors Amagansett Village, Beachfront Area Accessibility, Scenic views, Quiet surroundings
Budget Amagansett Village, Napeague Affordable dining options, Access to public transit, Community events
Luxury Amagansett Beachfront, Private Estates Gourmet dining experiences, Spa facilities, Private beach access